Sleepers · round 12+ or undrafted
Who finds the bodies
Late picks and waiver-wire nobodies who outscored their draft slot. Ranked by points over replacement at the position, so a QB12 doesn't get credit for existing. Credit goes to whoever drafted him, or whoever grabbed him first.
Sleeper hunters
all seasons| # | Manager | Top-5 sleepers | #1 finishes | Value over repl. | Best find |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andrew Sharpe | 12 | 2 | 958.80 |  James Conner 2018 · RB · +127.70 · picked up before week 1 |
| 2 | Josh Stubblefield | 6 | 0 | 408.30 |  Eric Ebron 2018 · TE · +101.70 · picked up before week 2 |
| 3 | Pierce Freeman | 5 | 1 | 428.80 |  Matthew Stafford 2025 · QB · +111.80 · picked up before week 3 |
| 4 | Michael Muralles | 5 | 2 | 416.20 |  George Kittle 2018 · TE · +138.20 · drafted #149 (round 13) |
| 5 | Jason Moyer | 5 | 1 | 392.50 |  Alvin Kamara 2017 · RB · +170.30 · picked up before week 6 |
| 6 | Logan Gamer | 5 | 0 | 352.70 |  Bucky Irving 2024 · RB · +86.50 · drafted #143 (round 12) |
| 7 | David Bruce | 5 | 1 | 286.00 |  Jameis Winston 2019 · QB · +75.00 · drafted #169 (round 15) |
| 8 | Will Mason | 4 | 1 | 292.30 |  Darren Waller 2019 · TE · +107.30 · picked up before week 1 |
| 9 | Bryan Provenzano | 4 | 1 | 275.20 |  Aaron Rodgers 2020 · QB · +111.00 · drafted #134 (round 12) |
| 10 | Chris Fiata | 3 | 1 | 265.40 |  Jordan Reed 2015 · TE · +113.50 · drafted #138 (round 12) |
| 11 | Jose Velez Capin | 2 | 0 | 130.70 |  Jared Cook 2018 · TE · +73.10 · picked up before week 2 |
| 12 | Conner Mitchell | 1 | 0 | 92.30 |  James Robinson 2020 · RB · +92.30 · drafted #135 (round 12) |
| 13 | Ryan McClane | 1 | 1 | 88.50 |  Matt Ryan 2016 · QB · +88.50 · drafted #168 (round 14) |
| 14 | Ian Spencer | 1 | 1 | 17.50 | Isaiah Likely 2026 · TE · +17.50 · drafted #137 (round 12) |
| 15 | Cory Hyatt | 1 | 0 | 12.00 | Pittsburgh Steelers 2026 · DST · +12.00 · drafted #158 (round 14) |
One credit per top-5 sleeper found (drafted round 12+ or picked up off waivers), tie-break on total value over replacement. The live season counts as it stands.
2026 · so far
17 eligible#1 · TE · pick 137
Isaiah Likely
+17.50
27.80 pts · replacement 10.30 · 0 starts
Found by Ian Spencer (NFCDEEZNUTZZ) — drafted #137 (round 12)
#2 · DST · pick 158
Pittsburgh Steelers
+12.00
18.00 pts · replacement 6.00 · 1 starts
Found by Cory Hyatt (Skeeze Machines) — drafted #158 (round 14)
#3 · K · pick 181
Evan McPherson
+9.00
19.00 pts · replacement 10.00 · 1 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (Secretary of War) — drafted #181 (round 16)
#4 · TE · pick 147
Dalton Kincaid
+7.70
18.00 pts · replacement 10.30 · 0 starts
Found by David Bruce (Sharpe is #1) — drafted #147 (round 13)
#5 · DST · pick 188
Jacksonville Jaguars
+7.00
13.00 pts · replacement 6.00 · 1 starts
Found by Jason Moyer (Diggs Spears Bass) — drafted #188 (round 16)
2025
38 eligible#1 · QB · undrafted
Matthew Stafford
+111.80
358.40 pts · replacement 246.60 · 11 starts
Found by Pierce Freeman (Team Billy) — picked up before week 3
#2 · QB · pick 145
Trevor Lawrence
+103.60
350.20 pts · replacement 246.60 · 6 starts
Found by Jason Moyer (Diggs Chase Chubb) — drafted #145 (round 13)
#3 · QB · pick 147
Caleb Williams
+78.60
325.20 pts · replacement 246.60 · 3 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (Secretary of War) — drafted #147 (round 13)
#4 · QB · pick 175
Dak Prescott
+77.20
323.80 pts · replacement 246.60 · 7 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Good Jeantys) — drafted #175 (round 15)
#5 · RB · undrafted
Kenny Gainwell
+74.60
221.30 pts · replacement 146.70 · 6 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Good Jeantys) — picked up before week 3
2024
36 eligible#1 · QB · undrafted
Baker Mayfield
+102.90
381.80 pts · replacement 278.90 · 2 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (More Injuries? Sensational) — picked up before week 1
#2 · RB · pick 143
Bucky Irving
+86.50
244.40 pts · replacement 157.90 · 10 starts
Found by Logan Gamer (Tiddy Boy LaCroix) — drafted #143 (round 12)
#3 · TE · undrafted
Jonnu Smith
+81.70
222.30 pts · replacement 140.60 · 6 starts
Found by Logan Gamer (Tiddy Boy LaCroix) — picked up before week 1
#4 · DST · undrafted
Denver Broncos
+59.00
179.00 pts · replacement 120.00 · 12 starts
Found by Will Mason (Fine, I'll Do It Myself) — picked up before week 5
#5 · QB · pick 182
Jared Goff
+57.60
336.50 pts · replacement 278.90 · 9 starts
Found by Jose Velez Capin (Tu Puka Madre) — drafted #182 (round 16)
2023
37 eligible#1 · TE · pick 146
Sam LaPorta
+103.00
239.30 pts · replacement 136.30 · 11 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (LaPorta Potties) — drafted #146 (round 13)
#2 · WR · undrafted
Puka Nacua
+89.70
298.50 pts · replacement 208.80 · 15 starts
Found by Pierce Freeman (Team Billy) — picked up before week 2
#3 · RB · undrafted
Kyren Williams
+80.50
255.00 pts · replacement 174.50 · 11 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (LaPorta Potties) — picked up before week 2
#4 · QB · undrafted
Jordan Love
+65.20
330.10 pts · replacement 264.90 · 5 starts
Found by Will Mason (Just Dont Get Sacko) — picked up before week 2
#5 · TE · undrafted
Trey McBride
+45.20
181.50 pts · replacement 136.30 · 7 starts
Found by Bryan Provenzano (Give Me A Chubb) — picked up before week 8
2022
34 eligible#1 · QB · undrafted
Geno Smith
+71.80
314.90 pts · replacement 243.10 · 6 starts
Found by David Bruce (Night at The Museum) — picked up before week 5
#2 · DST · undrafted
New England Patriots
+69.00
186.00 pts · replacement 117.00 · 5 starts
Found by Logan Gamer (Fountain Hills Falcons) — picked up before week 5
#3 · RB · pick 142
Jamaal Williams
+67.40
225.90 pts · replacement 158.50 · 10 starts
Found by David Bruce (Night at The Museum) — drafted #142 (round 12)
#4 · QB · pick 192
Justin Fields
+63.90
307.00 pts · replacement 243.10 · 6 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (THE CONDOR HAS BEEN CLIPPED) — drafted #192 (round 16)
#5 · QB · pick 143
Kirk Cousins
+62.50
305.60 pts · replacement 243.10 · 7 starts
Found by Logan Gamer (Fountain Hills Falcons) — drafted #143 (round 12)
2021
35 eligible#1 · RB · undrafted
Cordarrelle Patterson
+86.00
234.60 pts · replacement 148.60 · 12 starts
Found by Michael Muralles (TEAM WILLY) — picked up before week 3
#2 · WR · undrafted
Hunter Renfrow
+73.50
259.10 pts · replacement 185.60 · 11 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Paninis And Payouts) — picked up before week 3
#3 · DST · undrafted
Dallas Cowboys
+64.00
185.00 pts · replacement 121.00 · 6 starts
Found by Michael Muralles (TEAM WILLY) — picked up before week 4
#4 · QB · pick 136
Joe Burrow
+63.20
328.20 pts · replacement 265.00 · 2 starts
Found by Jason Moyer (GOODBYE 4 GOOD LESSER THAN!) — drafted #136 (round 12)
#5 · TE · undrafted
Dalton Schultz
+61.80
208.80 pts · replacement 147.00 · 6 starts
Found by Pierce Freeman (Team Billy) — picked up before week 4
2020
37 eligible#1 · QB · pick 134
Aaron Rodgers
+111.00
388.30 pts · replacement 277.20 · 13 starts
Found by Bryan Provenzano (The GOAT House) — drafted #134 (round 12)
#2 · RB · pick 135
James Robinson
+92.30
250.40 pts · replacement 158.10 · 11 starts
Found by Conner Mitchell (Demsomes Poogie) — drafted #135 (round 12)
#3 · QB · pick 133
Ryan Tannehill
+74.10
351.40 pts · replacement 277.20 · 2 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (MOYERS BEING A BABY) — drafted #133 (round 12)
#4 · QB · undrafted
Justin Herbert
+65.60
342.80 pts · replacement 277.20 · 10 starts
Found by Bryan Provenzano (The GOAT House) — picked up before week 3
#5 · RB · undrafted
Mike Davis
+48.40
206.50 pts · replacement 158.10 · 10 starts
Found by Jason Moyer (GODSPEED MICHAEL) — picked up before week 3
2019
37 eligible#1 · TE · undrafted
Darren Waller
+107.30
221.00 pts · replacement 113.70 · 14 starts
Found by Will Mason (ANAL LYTICS) — picked up before week 1
#2 · DST · pick 174
New England Patriots
+99.00
232.00 pts · replacement 133.00 · 15 starts
Found by Chris Fiata (JPP's Finger Bangers) — drafted #174 (round 15)
#3 · TE · pick 140
Mark Andrews
+93.50
207.20 pts · replacement 113.70 · 13 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (The League of Sharpe Gets 1st) — drafted #140 (round 12)
#4 · QB · pick 159
Dak Prescott
+88.50
348.80 pts · replacement 260.30 · 14 starts
Found by Pierce Freeman (Team Billy) — drafted #159 (round 14)
#5 · QB · pick 169
Jameis Winston
+75.00
335.40 pts · replacement 260.30 · 7 starts
Found by David Bruce (MikeShit Himself4xSRyear) — drafted #169 (round 15)
2018
37 eligible#1 · TE · pick 149
George Kittle
+138.20
258.70 pts · replacement 120.50 · 9 starts
Found by Michael Muralles (FUCK hanuKKKah) — drafted #149 (round 13)
#2 · RB · undrafted
James Conner
+127.70
279.70 pts · replacement 152.00 · 12 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Dezperate 4 A Win) — picked up before week 1
#3 · TE · undrafted
Eric Ebron
+101.70
222.20 pts · replacement 120.50 · 14 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (Playoffs? Is That You?) — picked up before week 2
#4 · DST · undrafted
Chicago Bears
+77.00
190.00 pts · replacement 113.00 · 14 starts
Found by Pierce Freeman (Team Billy) — picked up before week 1
#5 · TE · undrafted
Jared Cook
+73.10
193.60 pts · replacement 120.50 · 14 starts
Found by Jose Velez Capin (Sucio Squad) — picked up before week 2
2017
38 eligible#1 · RB · undrafted
Alvin Kamara
+170.30
314.40 pts · replacement 144.10 · 11 starts
Found by Jason Moyer (KIA is a vastly Superior Machin) — picked up before week 6
#2 · DST · pick 137
Jacksonville Jaguars
+81.00
199.00 pts · replacement 118.00 · 14 starts
Found by Josh Stubblefield (Im Tanking) — drafted #137 (round 12)
#3 · QB · pick 166
Alex Smith
+57.30
295.20 pts · replacement 237.90 · 7 starts
Found by Michael Muralles (Michael Playoff Muralles) — drafted #166 (round 14)
#4 · DST · pick 184
Baltimore Ravens
+56.00
174.00 pts · replacement 118.00 · 14 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Nerd And A Jock) — drafted #184 (round 16)
#5 · RB · undrafted
Dion Lewis
+52.90
197.00 pts · replacement 144.10 · 5 starts
Found by Chris Fiata (JPP's Finger Bangers) — picked up before week 12
2016
26 eligible#1 · QB · pick 168
Matt Ryan
+88.50
347.50 pts · replacement 258.90 · 15 starts
Found by Ryan McClane (Sit N Spin) — drafted #168 (round 14)
#2 · RB · pick 178
Jay Ajayi
+70.70
215.30 pts · replacement 144.60 · 10 starts
Found by Michael Muralles (THE FUCKING CHAMP) — drafted #178 (round 15)
#3 · TE · undrafted
Kyle Rudolph
+63.60
209.00 pts · replacement 145.40 · 10 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Gamer Is A Salty Jew) — picked up before week 4
#4 · WR · undrafted
Davante Adams
+53.40
246.70 pts · replacement 193.30 · 10 starts
Found by Bryan Provenzano (The GOAT House) — picked up before week 8
#5 · RB · pick 160
Tevin Coleman
+46.50
191.10 pts · replacement 144.60 · 0 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (Gamer Is A Salty Jew) — drafted #160 (round 14)
2015
24 eligible#1 · TE · pick 138
Jordan Reed
+113.50
244.20 pts · replacement 130.70 · 14 starts
Found by Chris Fiata (JPP's Finger Bangers) — drafted #138 (round 12)
#2 · RB · pick 147
David Johnson
+64.10
209.80 pts · replacement 145.70 · 8 starts
Found by David Bruce (No Trades) — drafted #147 (round 13)
#3 · TE · pick 150
Tyler Eifert
+60.80
191.50 pts · replacement 130.70 · 14 starts
Found by Will Mason (How I Lucked Your Mother) — drafted #150 (round 13)
#4 · TE · undrafted
Benjamin Watson
+59.80
190.50 pts · replacement 130.70 · 3 starts
Found by Andrew Sharpe (ALL I DO IS WIN BY .1 POINTS) — picked up before week 9
#5 · DST · pick 178
Kansas City Chiefs
+53.00
173.00 pts · replacement 120.00 · 10 starts
Found by Logan Gamer (IM TILTING) — drafted #178 (round 15)
Drafted at pick 133+ (round 12+) or undrafted, and on a league roster at some point. Ranked by points over replacement: season fantasy points (FantasyPros, league scoring) minus the position's replacement level (QB14 / RB30 / WR30 / TE14 / K12 / DST12 by season points). Season points from FantasyPros; roster history from ESPN box scores.